Duke of Monmouth on the Run July 1685

                                           Destination Poole, Dorset ?

                                                



After the Battle of Sedgemoor debacle on 6th July 1685, the Duke of Monmouth and Lord Grey went on the run.They were caught separately on 8th July 1685. But where were they heading? Historian and specialist on the Monmouth Rebellion Peter Earle favoured Poole as Monmouth and Lord Grey's destination,and the hope of a ship out of England. EARLE Battle of Sedgemoor historian John Tincey shares this view TINCEY  along with biographer Laura Brennan. BRENNAN 2018 Another biographer,  Anna Keay, suggested that Monmouth and Lord Grey were both heading towards sympathisers living in Sussex, possibly to Lord Grey's estates KEAY 2016. The latter seems less likely as the authorities were bound to search any house or land connnected to Lord Grey, but on the other hand Monouth had successfully cultivated support in Chichester and had been regularly fox hunting in the surrounding district from 1679-1683. KEAY 2020

The ships that conveyed Monmouth and his supporters from the Dutch Republic, moored outside Lyme Regis, had been impounded by the Royal Navy. Certainly Monmouth was heading south east towards Poole, a port then on the eastern edge of Dorset ( before county boundary changes). But he was captured  further east at Verwood, towards the New Forest, so had bypassed the town by about 13 miles. Monmouth may have simply got lost or wanted to hide in the Forest and head for Poole later. 

Probably only a few citizens of Poole joined the Monmouth Rebellion-records aren't clear. Upon hearing of Monmouth landing at Lyme, the Dorset militia soon mobilised and kept their loyalty to the Crown, preventing  potential supporters from heading west. Poole -just as Lyme Regis- had supported Parliament during the Civil Wars and the two towns, at opposite sides of Dorset, were never taken by the Royalists. There might be sympathisers in Poole, or at least people who if they recognised the Duke on the run, would look the other way.Also, as the largest port of Dorset, a stranger in the town would not necessarily attract notice. In fact Monmouth on his own in the countryside was soon identified. 

The disadvantage of Poole was that firstly the authorities might also consider the town as a possible destination for Monmouth to aim for. Secondly, the town was quite easy to seal off. Built on a peninsula, the road leading into Poole flooded regularly.VINE Up until the Civil Wars, there was a defensive wall and a town gate which could be closed, VINE though these fortifications might have changed during the reign of Charles II. Poole harbour is the second largest in the world. Its entrance is now quite narrow as changes to the Channel tides have built up sands, but would have been wider in the past and less easy for a Royal Navy ship to blockade. 

It is not quite clear where the unfortunate duke was heading if he was returning to exile. He was banned from the Dutch Republic by Stadtholder William, (our future William III) who did not wish to quarrel with his father in law James II.  Yet Monmouth had sympathisers there, particularly in Amsterdam.It is also possible that William might ignore Monmouth's presence as long as he led a quiet existence  in Dutch territory, and didn't get anywhere near Court. Catholic France would not be a safe sanctuary with Louis XIV launching his own persecution of Protestants. Perhaps Monmouth was hoping to somehow journey by small boat or yacht from Poole to another part of Britain. 

On 21st September 1685 11 of the Monmouth rebels were executed at Poole, part of the Bloody Assizes presided by Judge Jeffries. WARWALKS The authorities were keen to stagger the trials and executions across a wider area than that covered by the Rebellion The rebels who were put to death in Poole were : 

William Dillany, serge weaver of Honiton, in Monmouth’s Army

Andrew Ellis (alias Cossins), of Thorncombe, in Monmouth’s Army

William Hardiman, yeoman of Thorncombe, in Monmouth’s Army

Nicholas Hoare, tanner of Colyton,  in Monmouth’s Army

Thomas Jenkins, in Monmouth’s Army

William Martin, potter of Honiton, in Monmouth’s Army

John Pulling, in Monmouth’s Army

Joseph Restorick, husbandman of Colyton, in Monmouth’s Army

Robert Salter, serge weaver of Upottery, in Monmouth’s Army

Andrew Tozer, in Monmouth’s Army

Samuel Waldron, of Sidbury, in Monmouth’s Army

( Information from 'War Walks' )

But there is nothing to suggest that they were local men. Most appeared to have been from the heartland of the Rebellion, namely Somerset or East Devon, and died through being hanged drawn and quartered. Body parts would be placed on display. There were other penalties for captured such as transportation, prison, public flogging, but even then it's difficult to trace Poole men from the records. 

The Duke of Monmouth was not able to have the same success as his father Charles II in evading capture but executed on 15th July 1685. 

UPDATE 

Mark Vine has kindly pointed out that Charles II ordered the Towngate fortifications to be demolished when he visited Poole. 

This visit took place on 15 September 1665 , and it is claimed that the Duke of Monmouth accompanied the king. He would have been 16 at the time. 
How Unfortunate was Monmouth  Poole Museum Society blogpost. 


Picture Credit 

1873 illustration of Monmouth's capture :  In the Public Domain courtesy of Wikipedia UK

Full details


Sources 

Books

The Duke of Monmouth Life and Rebellion, Laura BRENNAN, Pen & Sword, 2018

James II and VII Britain's Last Catholic King Laura BRENNAN, Pen & Sword, 2023

Monmouth's Rebels-The Road to Sedgemoor 1685, Peter EARLE, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1977

The Last Royal Rebel- The Life and Death of James Duke of Monmouth ,Anna KEAY, Bloomsbury, 2017

Sedgemoor 1685 Marlborough's first victory  John TINCEY, Pen & Sword, 2005 

The Crabchurch Conspiracy- The True Story of Dorset's Bloodiest Secrets, Mark VINE, Sherrens Prington Ltd. Weymouth 2013 

Others

Monmouth Rebels Executed at Poole  21st September 1685 , from 'War Walks' website 

Poole Museum Society Blog  Miscarriage and Disorder -Poole in the 1680s 

The Rebel and the Fox  Youtube Video about the Duke of Monmouth with an emphasis on the West Sussex connection presented by Anna KEAY from 2020. ( Last accessed 13th November 2026) 

Other Blogs by Michael Bully

A Burnt Ship               17th century history & literature 

Bleak Chesney Wold  19th century history & literature 

World War 2 Poetry    As it says on the tin 


Social Media 

Now using one Bluesky account: Do join me. 

Michael Bully @bleakchesneywold.bsky.social  

Instagram  

Mr Bleak (@MrBleak5 )


 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review 'Fighting For Liberty '-Stephen M Carter

Review : The Duke of Monmouth- Life and Rebellion

Sedgemoor -52 poem collection by Malcolm Povey from 2006